Christian Death

dogmanstar schrieb:

"I'm a fan of Rozz" - and Rozz's fans makes you vomit, as per your tagging?I wonder why. If you want to make yourself clear, do that with respect to others, we are here to discuss the music we love, not to offend or harass each other. Although silence should really be the choice for some people, words speak for themselves, the very words that you chose, "dear".

Profil anzeigen | dogmanstar einen Shout schreiben

Tu_Fui_Ego_Eris schrieb:

Ha-ha, dear, I'm very far from being homophobic, so sad to disappoint you. As I already said - I'm a fan of Rozz - and didn't care about anybody's s. orientation. What i meant was clear enough. It's kind of pity that you distort it’s meaning in desired direction, so you can be able to point a finger at me. "Oh, he said the G. word! Get that homophobic mother fucker!" If you like burning crosses on a nigger's lawn, then be my guest, but not everything is in black and white. ;) P.S. Sometimes, when you don't have anything to say - silence is better solution.

Profil anzeigen | Tu_Fui_Ego_Eris einen Shout schreiben

dogmanstar schrieb:

"Gay shit." Ha. Proud to see that Valor's "street team" has homophobes (2nd time I read it from this user, so...).

Profil anzeigen | dogmanstar einen Shout schreiben

N808a4 schrieb:

MusicBrainz (one, two), Amazon (one, two), and even Wikipedia seem to recognize the fact at hand: there were two different bands called Christian Death. Why doesn't last.fm recognize it also? Why allow one band to select an official image to the exclusion of another band of equal popularity that shares the same page? I don't mean to give the impression that I think it's big deal; I'm just wondering where this exceptionalism is coming from.

Profil anzeigen | N808a4 einen Shout schreiben

N808a4 schrieb:

I had a long-winded reply posted earlier, but deleted it because who cares. What I'm really wondering is: what does a legal artifact have to do with correctly documenting the music we're scrobbling? It's a fact that we have two separate bands occupying this page; Rozz continued to release new albums as Christian Death after splitting with Valor, even while Valor was simultaneously releasing albums as Christian Death. It's a fact that both of these bands are popular in their own right - just take a look at the scrobbles here. These facts remain factual even if they're deemed illegal facts later on.

Profil anzeigen | N808a4 einen Shout schreiben

Of_Inexistency schrieb:

did you all even glance at the link I just posted? if we can all band together in big numbers, and get last fm to allow us to choose which artist pictures we want for our own profiles, this whole forced artist/label thing will hardly matter anymore! yes, Valor's (unwanted) presence will always be flashing here on Christian Death's main page, but as long as I get to see nice Rozz pics in my library on MY personal last fm profile, I am completely satisfied. besides, the whole idea of everyone fighting over which picture gets to the top is extremely frustrating and just doesn't work one way or the other anyway.

Profil anzeigen | Of_Inexistency einen Shout schreiben

Tu_Fui_Ego_Eris schrieb:

BadBlackFlag, Tainted Love is the most listened track of Marilyn Manson on Last.Fm, but every fan knows it's not cause of the quality, but the popularity of the song. Very often the most easy to assimilate songs are at the top of the charts. And when someone new to CD comes to this page he will see nothing else than "hallelujah OTOP, fuck Valor" in the shout box, you've done good hate work there, congrats! Rozz would be so proud. :) Gosh, I used to like him so much more before i came to this hysterical page.

Profil anzeigen | Tu_Fui_Ego_Eris einen Shout schreiben

Tu_Fui_Ego_Eris schrieb:

When I’m waiting new CD album to come out, It will be kind of weird to see Rozz on the main pic, cause since 1985 he’s out of the band willingly. Now – you can just continue with all your ‘No true Cd without Rozz” comments if it makes your day. For me Valor is the one who kept CD alive for such a long time and never gave up of it’s idea, and developed it in sо varried ways.

Profil anzeigen | Tu_Fui_Ego_Eris einen Shout schreiben

Tu_Fui_Ego_Eris schrieb:

The “he shouldn't have carried on as Christian Death” part kind of amaze me. It’s not like you took candy from a little baby, you know. Rozz resurrected CD with the help of Valor, CD was already dead before that. They made next two albums together. Then Rozz tried to kill CD again – this child that he claimed is very special for him? Interesting, cause some years ago, in some interviews, he claims he didn’t give a shit for CD anymore, and wanted to start something different. Well, if I’m Valor and the band is planning to go on tour after the release of new CD album, and then out of a sudden this “look guys, surprise! I’m out, sha-la-la” gay shit happens, I’ll definitely keep the band’s name, cause the fans will expect nothing less than this. Since Valor is a major part of CD from the very beginning of the resurrected band, of which later Rozz gave up once again, it’s more than logical that the main pic contains image of him and the current members.

Profil anzeigen | Tu_Fui_Ego_Eris einen Shout schreiben

BadBlackFlag schrieb:

All valor vocal albums together have just 300 thousand plays. Its about a half of OToP plays. I dont give a shit how many albums he released. It's all about quality, not quantity

Profil anzeigen | BadBlackFlag einen Shout schreiben

dogmanstar schrieb:

@EdenFeast, you should know that Rozz was also a composer in Catastrophe Ballet and Ashes. Sleepwalk and Face for instance were songs from the OTOP era - just for the record. He wrote all the lyrics as well. Valor is a vocalist since the 4th record, ok, but he even shouldn't have carried on as Christian Death in the 1st place, as Rozz asked him not to do that and he agreed to move on as Sin and Sacrifice. Gitane Demone and David Glass have gracefully provided their mea culpa in several interviews, so, it's like 3 against one. There is no math to be done. And @TheMannen, thanks for the reply, you were pretty cool, objective and straightforward.

Profil anzeigen | dogmanstar einen Shout schreiben

EdenFeast schrieb:

I'll be glad if Valor never puts Rozz pic here! Not because i have something against Rozz, but because of you people, that way you will not loose your reason to live and you will still have the chance to argue about the main pic! :) P.S. Just for the record. Valor on the main pic is far more reasonable, cuz he is in the band since the second album, as a guitar player and composer, and as a vocalist since the 4th. Rozz do the vocals in the first three and the composing only in the first one.... you do the math.

Profil anzeigen | EdenFeast einen Shout schreiben

TheMannen schrieb:

Yeah, that would obviously be the best solution, from a user's point of view. But since Valor's Christian Death are the ones with the legal rights to the name, they're the ones who can (and do, obviously) use Last.fm for promotion of their music, and as such are allowed to set an official image that they believe represents them the best (and apparently they think a picture of the current band does that). It's one of these cases where the "community" aspect of Last.fm clashes with the "artist promotion tool" part.

Profil anzeigen | TheMannen einen Shout schreiben

dogmanstar schrieb:

@The Mannen: can't we just be able to choose a picture we believe represents what most listeners/Last.fm users would like to see? Valor has the legal rights for the name indeed, but he didn't actually create the name of the band - no matter how some people try to reinvent history. Rozz Williams was the founder of the band, Valor was not involved in the band's first album in ANY way (that's Only Theatre of Pain, the most listened one here), so why couldn't we be able to choose a pic from that era? Or even with Valor AND Rozz (some pics of both of them appearing together are also available for choosing, and that would split credits and glory between the 2 of them). It's only democracy, you know...

Profil anzeigen | dogmanstar einen Shout schreiben

KET-er- schrieb:

WTF????!!!!

Profil anzeigen | KET-er- einen Shout schreiben

Laamp schrieb:

FUCK

Profil anzeigen | Laamp einen Shout schreiben

TheMannen schrieb:

So, forgive me for not knowing anything about this band, but this Valor guy is the legal owner of the name now, right? If so, I can't do anything about the official images (even though I did remove them yesterday... but now I've realized that that was probably not the right thing to do).

Profil anzeigen | TheMannen einen Shout schreiben

Of_Inexistency schrieb:

http://www.last.fm/group/I+want+to+choose+my+own+artist+picture

Profil anzeigen | Of_Inexistency einen Shout schreiben